Simplifying Bitcoin Units: A Divisive Idea

A new proposal, advocated by John Carvalho, aims to redefine the unit of measurement for Bitcoin. The idea? Replace decimal points with a presentation in whole numbers, where what we currently consider a satoshi would become the new “bitcoin.” This initiative sparks debates and reflections within the crypto community.

A new unit for better accessibility

John Carvalho, a prominent figure in the sector, has presented a proposal that would radically transform the way Bitcoin values are represented. Currently, one bitcoin (BTC) equals 100 million satoshis (the smallest unit of the currency). The new proposal redefines one bitcoin to represent what we today call a satoshi, completely removing the decimals.

For example, a transaction that appears today as “0.00010000 BTC” would become “10,000 bitcoins.” Carvalho argues that this change would make transactions more intuitive, especially for new users who are not familiar with fractional values.

“The decimal point is just a man-made abstraction“, explains Carvalho in his proposal, emphasizing that this simplification would align the display of Bitcoin with its fundamental protocol.

Logistical challenges and criticisms

This proposal is not without controversy. Critics point out several risks associated with such a change in unit. First, it could confuse current users who are accustomed to the current system, thereby increasing errors in transactions.

Moreover, electronic wallets and exchange platforms, developed to operate with the decimal format, would need to undergo significant modifications. This would pose considerable logistical challenges, involving substantial costs and coordination efforts within the Bitcoin ecosystem.

Finally, some experts believe that this reform could create unnecessary confusion for users, hindering the adoption of crypto. In 2017, a similar idea was proposed under the name “bits” (BIP 176) but failed to convince the community.

An educational challenge for Bitcoin

The reform proposed by Carvalho reignites a long-standing debate about the necessity of simplifying Bitcoin units to promote widespread adoption. While it promises better accessibility, it also raises complex questions regarding logistics and communication.

For now, no consensus is emerging on this issue. The Bitcoin community will need to weigh the benefits of simplification against the potential downsides to determine if this reform is worth implementing.

The proposal “One bitcoin = One Satoshi” embodies a bold effort to modernize and democratize the use of Bitcoin. However, its success will depend on the community’s ability to overcome technical obstacles and establish effective education to accompany this radical change.